#coding:utf-8 """ ID: issue-478 ISSUE: 478 TITLE: Left joining views with null fails DESCRIPTION: JIRA: CORE-149 FBTEST: bugs.core_0149 """ import pytest from firebird.qa import * db = db_factory() test_script = """ set list on; -- Initial comment by johnsparrowuk, 19/Mar/04 12:00 AM: recreate view currentpeople(k) as select 1 as k from rdb$database; recreate view finishedpeople(k) as select 1 as k from rdb$database; commit; recreate table mytable ( person varchar(20) not null, status int not null, primary key (person,status) ); recreate view currentpeople(person) as select distinct person as person from mytable where status = 1; recreate view finishedpeople(person) as select distinct person as person from mytable where status = 2; insert into mytable values ('john',1); insert into mytable values ('john',2); insert into mytable values ('fred',1); commit; -- This works fine: fred-null, john-john select * from currentpeople c left join finishedpeople f on c.person = f.person order by c.person, f.person ; -- This is as expected too: john-john select * from currentpeople c left join finishedpeople f on c.person = f.person where f.person = 'john' order by c.person, f.person ; -- WHATS HAPPENING HERE????? fred-null, JOHN-NULL where does the john-null come from??? select * from currentpeople c left join finishedpeople f on c.person = f.person where f.person is null order by c.person, f.person ; commit; --################################################# -- Alice F. Bird added a comment - 14/Jun/06 09:32 AM recreate table test ( id int not null, name varchar(15), pid integer ); insert into test(id, name, pid) values(1, 'Car', null); insert into test(id, name, pid) values(2, 'Engine', 1); insert into test(id, name, pid) values(3, 'Body', 1); insert into test(id, name, pid) values(4, 'Oil Filter',2); insert into test(id, name, pid) values(5, 'Air Filter',2); insert into test(id, name, pid) values(6, 'Door Left', 3); insert into test(id, name, pid) values(7, 'Door Right',3); commit; -- This query issued WRONG result on 1.5.6 -- (because first data source - 'TEST' - has not alias) select * from test left outer join test t2 on test.pid=t2.id order by test.id, t2.id ; -- This works fine: select * from test t1 left outer join test t2 on t1.pid=t2.id order by t1.id, t2.id ; """ act = isql_act('db', test_script) expected_stdout = """ PERSON fred PERSON PERSON john PERSON john PERSON john PERSON john PERSON fred PERSON ID 1 NAME Car PID ID NAME PID ID 2 NAME Engine PID 1 ID 1 NAME Car PID ID 3 NAME Body PID 1 ID 1 NAME Car PID ID 4 NAME Oil Filter PID 2 ID 2 NAME Engine PID 1 ID 5 NAME Air Filter PID 2 ID 2 NAME Engine PID 1 ID 6 NAME Door Left PID 3 ID 3 NAME Body PID 1 ID 7 NAME Door Right PID 3 ID 3 NAME Body PID 1 ID 1 NAME Car PID ID NAME PID ID 2 NAME Engine PID 1 ID 1 NAME Car PID ID 3 NAME Body PID 1 ID 1 NAME Car PID ID 4 NAME Oil Filter PID 2 ID 2 NAME Engine PID 1 ID 5 NAME Air Filter PID 2 ID 2 NAME Engine PID 1 ID 6 NAME Door Left PID 3 ID 3 NAME Body PID 1 ID 7 NAME Door Right PID 3 ID 3 NAME Body PID 1 """ @pytest.mark.version('>=3') def test_1(act: Action): act.expected_stdout = expected_stdout act.execute() assert act.clean_stdout == act.clean_expected_stdout